Donate

Does Richard Burgon know what a woman is?

The Labour MP was asked if only women can get pregnant. He dodged the question.

spiked

Topics Feminism Politics UK

Want to read spiked ad-free? Become a spiked supporter.

Not for the first time, Labour MP Richard Burgon is confused.

This week, appearing on the BBC’s Politics Live, Burgon repeatedly refused to say whether maternity law should refer to the pregnant ‘woman’ or pregnant ‘person’. He said the question was a ‘distraction’.

— BBC Politics (@BBCPolitics) February 10, 2021

The government is pursuing a bill which would change maternity law, giving greater scope for some MPs to take leave when pregnant or after giving birth. When explaining who is to be eligible for maternity leave, the bill refers to the pregnant ‘person’ concerned. A number of Tory MPs want the language amended to refer to women.

After all, it isn’t people who get pregnant – it’s women. It’s bizarre that Burgon finds this so difficult to grasp. And it’s startling that he dismissed women’s identity – and biological make-up – as merely a ‘distraction’.

Enjoying Spiked?

Support us with an instant, one-off donation.

Please wait...
Thank you!

Pushed on the issue, Burgon said, ‘this is the kind of culture debate that the right-wing press have tried to run in the 1980s’. For him, the issue of what defines a woman – upon which all women’s sex-based rights depend – is apparently nothing more than the product of a tabloid hate campaign.

Burgon is not the only one in a muddle. Fellow Labour MP Stella Creasy is mixed up, too. Speaking on the BBC’s Today programme this morning, she also dodged the issue, saying, ‘It is a moment of privilege to be concerned about the drafting of the bill rather than the scope of the bill’.

But it should not be hard for a politician to acknowledge that only women can get pregnant. It does not denote ‘privilege’ to want the law to reflect basic fact.

Picture by: Getty.

This is what we're up against...

A media ecosystem dominated by a handful of billionaire owners, bad actors spreading disinformation online and the rich and powerful trying to stop us publishing stories. But we have you on our side. Supporters help to fund our journalism and those who choose All-access digital enjoy exclusive extras:

  1. Unlimited articles in our app and ad-free reading on all devices
  2. Exclusive newsletter and far fewer asks for support
  3. Full access to the Guardian Feast app

If you can, please support us on a monthly basis and make a big impact in support of open, independent journalism. Thank you.

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Only spiked supporters and patrons, who donate regularly to us, can comment on our articles.

Join today